From 1948 until Today: A History of Silencing Israeli Army Whistleblowers

Mar 23 2016 / 4:26 pm
'Former soldiers confirmed that over 200 Palestinians had been massacred at Tantura, south of Haifa.'
'Former soldiers confirmed that over 200 Palestinians had been massacred at Tantura, south of Haifa.'

By Jonathan Cook – Nazareth

One might expect that only historians would care to revisit the 1948 war that created Israel. And yet the debate about what constitutes truth and myth from that period still provokes raw emotions.

Much rests on how those events are reconstructed, not least because the shock waves have yet to subside. Israelis fear, and Palestinians crave, a clearer picture of the past because it would powerfully illuminate the present. It might also influence the international community’s proposed solutions for the conflict.

That is why the unearthing of an Israeli soldier’s letter from 1948 detailing what was probably the war’s worst massacre – one long buried by Israel – is of more than historical significance.

It comes as Moshe Yaalon, the defense minister, this week accused Breaking the Silence, an Israeli organisation that exposes military abuses, of “treason” for collecting evidence from the army’s current whistle-blowers.

Western understandings of the 1948 war – what Palestinians term their Nakba, or catastrophe – are dominated by an enduring Israeli narrative. Israel’s army, it is said, abided by a strict moral code. Palestinians left not because of Israel’s actions but on the orders of Arab leaders.

In this rendering, the Palestinians’ mass dispossession was the fault of the Arab world – and a solution for the millions of today’s refugees lies with their host countries.

For decades Israel’s chief concession to the truth was an admission that a massacre took place just outside Jerusalem, at Deir Yassin.

Israel claimed the atrocity was the exception that proved the rule: a rogue militia killed more than 100 villagers, violating Israel’s ethical codes in the chaotic weeks before statehood was declared.

Palestinians have always known of dozens of other large massacres of civilians from 1948 carried out by the Israeli army. The barbarity, they say, was intended to terrorize the native population into flight. This account puts responsibility on Israel for taking the refugees back.

But history is written by the victor.

In recent decades a few brave Israeli scholars have chipped away at the official facade. In the late 1990s a Haifa University student collected testimonies from former soldiers confirming that over 200 Palestinians had been massacred at Tantura, south of Haifa. After the findings were made public, he was pilloried and stripped of his degree.

A decade ago, the historian Ilan Pappe wrote a groundbreaking book, The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine, arguing that massacres like the one at Tantura were exploited to drive out Palestinians. He and others noted the suggestive titles of military operations such as “Broom” and soldiers’ orders to “clean” areas.

Pappe now lives in academic exile in the UK.

The biggest obstacle to shifting Israeli and western perceptions of 1948 has been the lack of a clear paper trail connecting the political leadership to the massacres. Israel locked away bundles of documentation precisely not to jeopardize the official narrative.

But things are changing slowly.

Last year a key deception was punctured: that Israel urged many of the war’s 750,000 Palestinian refugees to return. In a letter to Haifa’s leaders shortly after the city’s Palestinians were expelled, David Ben Gurion, Israel’s first prime minister, demanded that any return be barred.

Now another letter, located by Israeli historian Yair Auron and published last week for the first time in English by the Haaretz newspaper, trashes the idea of an ethical Israel army.

Written by Shabtai Kaplan, a soldier and journalist, the letter confirms long-held suspicions of a massacre – one that dwarfs Deir Yassin – at Dawaymeh, near Hebron. Soldiers executed hundreds of men, women and children who offered no resistance.

The massacre, near the end of the war, was carried out by elite troops under the command of Yitzhak Sadeh. He developed the Israeli army’s famous doctrine of “purity of arms”.

Kaplan argues that the Dawaymeh massacre was part of “a system of expulsion and destruction”, with a clear goal: “The fewer Arabs who remain, the better.”

Kaplan’s letter was consigned to the vaults, as were so many other documents from 1948 that officials considered too damaging.

Nearly seven decades later, in an age of 24-hour news and social media, Israel is still desperately trying to conceal its darkest episodes by bullying the army’s current whistle-blowers.

Last week Benjamin Netanyahu’s government launched an investigation into Breaking the Silence. On Sunday Netanyau called the collection of soldiers’ testimonies “intolerable”, indicating that he may try to ban the group.

It is hard not to see parallels between the cover-ups of 1948 and those of today. Breaking the Silence’s disclosures, especially those relating to Israel’s series of attacks on Gaza, each of which has left hundreds of civilians dead, similarly give the lie to the army’s continuing claims of ethical behavior.

In his 1948 letter, Kaplan observed of the failure by the political leadership to hold anyone to account for the massacres: “Inaction is in itself encouragement.”

Israel’s politicians hoped then that the Palestinians could be quickly terrorized from their lands. Decades later, the atrocities continue – and to the same end. But Israel must face facts: the days when such systematic brutality could be kept under wraps are now over.

– Jonathan Cook won the Martha Gellhorn Special Prize for Journalism. His latest books are “Israel and the Clash of Civilisations: Iraq, Iran and the Plan to Remake the Middle East” (Pluto Press) and “Disappearing Palestine: Israel’s Experiments in Human Despair” (Zed Books). He contributed this article to Visit:

Posted by on Mar 23 2016 . Filed under Articles, Commentary . You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 . You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.

4 Comments for “From 1948 until Today: A History of Silencing Israeli Army Whistleblowers”


    i wouldn t have called this a war. as far as i know the israelis attacked un- or poorly armed palestinians. war implicites two different camps with equal arms (or possibilities). it s a bit like calling war the agressions on gaza.

    • Anonymous

      As a point-of-fact, no. The armies of Egypt, Syria, Jordan, as well as some Iraqi units, did, in fact, attack the bew State of Israel

  2. GARY


  3. Khatija Suleman

    This is not a war, it’s a “Palestinian Holocaust” don’t need to be a rocket scientist to establish that Israel is the world’s most well funded terrorist organization,The Zionist State has incoherently displaced hundreds and thousands of natives, murdering and imprisoning those left behind in the world’s largest open air prison, their wanton cruelty does not at any point exclude the innocent defenseless women and children in Gaza, infact we have seen the inhuman strategies used by IDF during the Seige in summer 2014 where their targets were these vulnerable defenceless Palestinans,”kill the women and children eventually Palestine will cease to exist”…There is simply no justification!!!

Leave a Comment

Please insert the correct number.

The Free Zone | Blog

  • June 27, 2016

    Rafah Crossing to Be Opened for Four Days

    By Palestine Chronicle Staff - The Palestinian Embassy in Cairo has announced today that the Egyptian authorities will open the Rafah crossing for four days, starting Wednesday, 29 June, 2016. - The crossing will operate on Wednesday, Thursday, shut down on Friday and re-open on Saturday and Sunday. - - The Egyptian authorities opened the Rafah crossing earlier... More →
  • June 27, 2016

    Ban Ki-Moon Visits Tel Aviv and Ramallah

    UN Secretary-General, BanKi-Moon, will today visit Israeli Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, Israeli President,ReuvenRivlin, and Palestinian Authority (PA) President, Mahmoud Abbas, reported. - According to the Israeli newspaper Israel Today, BanKi-Moon expected to listen to reports by senior Israeli security officials regarding the Israeli policy in the occupied West Bank and the Gaza Strip. He is expected... More →
  • June 27, 2016

    Ramallah Visit by OIC Secretary-General Cancelled

    A visit by Iyad bin Amin Madani, Secretary-General theOrganization of the Islamic Cooperation, to the West Bank city of Ramallah, has been cancelled, a senior PLO official said. - PLO Executive Committee member, Ahmed Majdalani, said the visit, which was due to take place on Sunday, has been postponed indefinitely. - Madani was scheduled to arrive in Ramallah for a two-day visit to meet Palestinian Authority President,... More →
  • June 27, 2016

    Quds Press Editor's Detention Extended by Israel

    An Israeli court has extended the detention of Ahmed Al-Betawi, editor at Quds Press International News Agency, for eight days, claiming further investigations are needed, his legal team said yesterday. - Lawyer, Gamal Mohamed, added that the investigation was taking place in the Petah Tikva detention center where Al-Betawi was detained since his arrest at his house in Nablus last Monday. - Mohamed pointed out that the... More →
  • June 27, 2016

    Official Stats: 'Israel is the Only State which Legalized Torture Inside its Prisons'

    PLO’s Prisoners and Freed Prisoners Committee stated yesterday that “all prisoners jailed by Israel were tortured,” including women, the elderly and children, Quds Press reported. - In a statement, Abdul-NaserFerwana, Director of Studies and Documentation Department at the committee, said that Israeli torture aims to “harm prisoners physically and mentally”. - The statement, which marked theInternational... More →

Recent Articles

Support Palestine Chronicle
Support Palestine Chronicle
"The Palestine Chronicle is a beacon. History, witness, analysis and ways forward are here, written with authority and humanity. Long may it publish." — John Pilger.
Subscribe to Newsletter
Enter your email address to subscribe to our mailing list.
I Remember My Name
Jerusalem Interrupted: Modernity and Colonial Transformation 1917-present
My Father Was A Freedom Fighter
Disclaimer RSS Feed Contact us Donation Popup
© Copyright 1999-2016 All rights reserved
Powered By MediaSeniors