On Palestine: Be Warned of ‘Solidarity Capture’

Mar 18 2016 / 5:50 pm

By Iqbal Jassat

As South Africa emerged from the annual calendar event known as #IsraelApartheidWeek (IAW), the country has plunged into an abyss of shame following huge controversies arising from allegations of “state capture”.

Dark, threatening clouds gathered around the Presidency and the ruling African National Congress (ANC) to come clean on whether key ministerial positions are “selected” by an unelected family who are known to wield enormous financial clout. Known as the Gupta’s, the family which originates from India, has acquired a sizable chunk of wealth in a relatively short time since setting up in SA during the post-Apartheid era.

In the midst of the current political storm which has consumed public interest and media content, fortunately, the Palestinian question remains alive.

In addition to the current distraction, South African supporters of Apartheid Israel also tried to derail IAW. By pulling off a diplomatic stunt in the middle of it, they hoped to distract public attention away from IAW and claim “victory” of sorts.

Whether they considered the consequences of their action when flying out Israel’s Dore Gold to meet his SA counterpart in Pretoria, or not, clearly the fall out has not gone the Hasbara (Israeli propaganda) way.

The sum total of the brief respite enjoyed by them consisted of a photo opportunity and exaggerated claims. The picture used to whip up support for Israel’s “major foreign policy success” in SA, depicts Gold alongside an official from the Department of International Relations (DIRCO).

So while the visit has been hailed by Israel as an important breakthrough, that no other picture has been broadcast, underlines the fact that no high profile member of the Zuma presidency had met with Gold.

As for claims that purported to be a “joint” statement, this has been exposed as a hoax. The only statement that has been doing the rounds alongside the picture, is the one issued by Israel’s ministry of foreign affairs. To claim that it is a “joint” statement, is to mislead and misrepresent.

As various university campuses hosted IAW events around the country, Israel’s lobby invested huge funds to counter the Apartheid narrative. By putting together a Zionist road show and showcasing a Palestinian academic, they hoped to derail IAW activities.

Of course, whether they bargained for it or not, the reality is that any effort to shadow events inevitably raises the profile of the main event. In this case the main event has been IAW. And the result? Renewed public focus on the question of Palestine and its ongoing freedom struggle against Apartheid Israel.

Indeed, the Palestinian academic used by the Zionist lobby to downplay and neutralise IAW activities, could not but agree on key Palestinian demands: Occupation is unsustainable, Wall cannot bring security and Settlements are illegal.

One can imagine the pain of local pro-Israel lobbyists having to grind their collective teeth at being confronted with key elements of Apartheid: Occupation, Wall and Settlements, by their own guest nogal.

Also adding to the drama were the series of articles on Palestine by online publication Daily Vox. Obviously timed to coincide with IAW, the series raised tough questions, particularly on the effectiveness of Palestinian solidarity. One that featured political analyst Steven Friedman, made a number of important observations which were highly critical of the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) campaign in SA.

Amongst failures of the BDS which Friedman listed, he claimed that instead of capturing a groundswell of support, it actually contributed to boosting Zionist activism.

But the piece by Minhaj Jeenah, which provided a comprehensive and objective analysis of Palestinian solidarity work in SA, led to questions being raised about Daily Vox’s purpose in running the series. Was it educational or deliberately timed to detract from IAW? These questions and more arose when Jeenah, on his Facebook post explained how Daily Vox attempted to rearrange his piece. He resisted and demanded that his original text be published without the changes desired by them. Changes, he explained would have positioned his article as an attack on BDS.

IAW2016 survived. The issue of Palestine has not evaporated into thin air. Successes claimed by pro-Israel lobbyists are questionable. And whatever dirty linen was exposed, has inadvertently led to renewed determination by various formations of Palestinian solidarity to take heed of legitimate criticisms and reshape their campaigns.

And in the midst of debates on “state capture”, an abiding lesson on the question of Palestine, is to avoid “solidarity capture”.

– Iqbal Jassat is an acclaimed writer, analyst and commentator and one of the founder members of Media Review Network in Johannesburg. His analysis is featured regularly in mainstream and alternate media outlets around the world. He contributed this article to PalestineChronicle.com. Visit: Media Review Network

Posted by on Mar 18 2016 . Filed under Articles, Commentary . You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 . You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.

Leave a Comment

Please insert the correct number.

The Free Zone | Blog

  • May 31, 2016

    Gaza Runners Denied Derry Marathon Visa Sparks Anger

    Two Gaza runners, Nader Al Massri and Sami Nateel have been denied a visa by the British Immigration authorities to attend a Derry Marathon, the Palestine Solidarity Campaign has revealed. The Irish Palestine Solidarity Campaign (I.P.S.C.) has branded the decision “inexplicable”. - “We are hugely disappointed and angered at this decision. There was a large group of Palestinians who came to the Derry marathon last... More →
  • May 31, 2016

    Israel Re-mapped West Bank Land to Expand Settlement Construction: Report

    Israel has re-mapped over 15,000 acres of land in the West Bank in an apparent attempt to expand illegal settlement construction, Haaretz reported. - The re-mapping was reportedly completed in 2015 by a special team called 'Blue Line,' working under the Civil Administration. - A total of 240 acres were mapped near the settlement of Nokdim, and almost one acre near Gitit. Almost 11 acres mapped near Tarkumiya are not... More →
  • May 31, 2016

    UNRWA Suspends Operations in Northern West Bank for One Day

    According to Palestinian refugee committees in the West Bank, The United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestinian Refugees (UNRWA) had suspended its services in northern West Bank for one day over an “aid distribution dispute.” - Husni Odeh, a spokesperson for refugee camp committees in the northern West Bank stated that UNRWA had officially notified the refugee camp committees of its decision to suspend... More →
  • May 31, 2016

    Breaking News: Egypt to Open Rafah Crossing for Four Days

    By Palestine Chronicle Staff - The Palestinian Ministry of Interior in Gaza announced today that the Egyptian authorities have informed the Ministry of its decision to open the Rafah Crossing for four days starting from tomorrow. - The crossing will open on Wednesday and Thursday and shut down on Friday, and re-open again Saturday and Sunday. - Some 30,000 Palestinians are registered to travel via the Rafah border and... More →
  • May 30, 2016

    Palestinian Schoolgirl Expelled from Speech Contest Grand Final

    Leanne Mohamad, the 15-year-old student at Wanstead High School in London, who won a regional final of the Jack Petchey Speak Out Challenge on her stories of the Nakba, has been expelled from the competition. - Leanne Mohamad, won the Speak Out Challenge with her speech ‘Birds not Bombs’, in which she details the historical and current reality for Palestinians under Israeli occupation. - However, her speech was met... More →
Support Palestine Chronicle
Support Palestine Chronicle
"The Palestine Chronicle is a beacon. History, witness, analysis and ways forward are here, written with authority and humanity. Long may it publish." — John Pilger.
Subscribe to Newsletter
Enter your email address to subscribe to our mailing list.
I Remember My Name
Jerusalem Interrupted: Modernity and Colonial Transformation 1917-present
My Father Was A Freedom Fighter
Disclaimer RSS Feed Contact us Donation Popup
© Copyright 1999-2016 PalestineChronicle.com. All rights reserved
Powered By MediaSeniors