‘Jewish State’ Recognition Urged

Israel’s defence minister has said that Arabs must recognize his country as a Jewish state before an independent Palestinian state can be created.

Ehud Barak told a news conference in Cairo on Sunday that there would be "intense efforts" in the coming weeks to set out the way forward in peace talks, but more needed to be done before a two-state solution became a reality.

"More steps must be taken in order to reach a situation where it is possible for Israelis and Palestinians to live in two states side by side in peace and with mutual respect," Barak said after the talks.

But he said that any resolution to the issue would need to include "respect for the nature of Israel as a state for the Jewish people".

Barak made the remarks after meeting Hosni Mubarak, the Egyptian president; Omar Suleiman, the intelligence chief; and Hussein Tantawi, the defence minister, in the Egyptian capital.

‘Peace and Security’

An Israeli official said Barak’s visit aimed to look at ways to move forward following a speech by Binyamin Netanyahu, the Israeli prime minister, in which he applied heavy conditions for the establishment of any future Palestinian state.

"He made it clear that the end result, the goal of the whole process is to have a situation where the two peoples, Palestinian and Israeli, are living side by side in two states in good neighborliness, peace and security," Barak said.

"It is a really unique opportunity for the peace process because the common interest is so apparent regarding the struggle against hegemonic Iran, against radical terrorism, against proliferation of nuclear weapons."

Egypt has dismissed the speech as flawed, while the Palestinians have complained that it effectively rules out a sovereign Palestinian state.

Netanyahu said any two-state solution would first require international guarantees that the Palestinians would not be allowed army or control over their own borders and airspace.

He also ruled Palestinians being allowed to return to their lands inside what is now Israel and said that Jerusalem would remain undivided, dismissing Palestinian claims that the east of the city should be the capital of any future state.

Recognition Issues

Palestinian leaders have previously refused to recognize Israel as a Jewish state because they believe it weakens the position of the 20 per cent of Israel’s citizens who are Arabs.

They also say it undermines the key demand for Palestinians refugees to return to the areas they left in 1948.

Mubarak has said that Israel’s call to be recognized as a state for the Jewish people undermined efforts to achieve peace and has said he told Netanyahu, who visited Egypt last month, that peace talks should resume where they left off.

"The call to recognize Israel as a Jewish state complicates things further and scuppers the possibilities for peace," state news agency MENA quoted Mubarak as saying at a military ceremony.

(The Palestine Chronicle is a registered 501(c)3 organization, thus, all donations are tax deductible.)
Our Vision For Liberation: Engaged Palestinian Leaders & Intellectuals Speak Out