By Iqbal Jassat
Is it a case of much ado about nothing or does it pose a significant challenge to undermine key components of Israel’s multi-layered myths?
From the heated backlash unleashed following an essay authored by Peter Beinart, it is clear that defenders of Zionism’s settler-colonial project view him as a “turncoat” and his views as an existential threat to the survival of Israel.
Who is Beinart and why the fury about his revised understanding of the path chosen by the Netanyahu regime to fulfill Zionist goals in “Eretz Israel”?
Beinart is described by Gideon Levy as one of American Jewry’s most prominent liberal intellectuals, an observant Jew who was raised in a Zionist home, who was 28 when he became the editor of The New Republic, and who later became a senior columnist at Haaretz.
His crime for which he is being lambasted as an antisemite and for the betrayal of Zionist ideals is succinctly captured by Levy: Beinart has said goodbye to the two-state solution and in effect issued a divorce decree to Zionism.
To illustrate how his earth-shattering new vision has attracted media attention, the New York Times headline said it all: “I No Longer Believe in a Jewish State.”
‘Love me, Love me, I’m a #liberal’: From #PeterBeinart to Santa Fe’s Liberal Mayor https://t.co/e7sVBzD3uf via @PalestineChron #Zionism #JewishState pic.twitter.com/KsKPfdw0rx
— @palestinechron (@PalestineChron) July 16, 2020
The storm resulting from Beinart’s essay which has engulfed Zionist ideologues in Israel, America, and across the Jewish diaspora, reminds us in South Africa of the angry reaction to struggle icon Ronnie Kasrils distancing himself from Israel.
More than two decades ago during the notorious reign of Ariel Sharon, Kasrils initiated and led a movement of a significant number of Jews, disgruntled with Israel’s persecution of Palestinians, under the banner “Not In My Name”.
Not only was he severely ostracized by Israel’s lobbyists who masquerade as Zionist gatekeepers of Judaism, he was “disowned” and reviled as a “self-hating Jew”.
The high-profile public position in defense of Palestinian rights by Kasrils, who at the time was a senior member of Nelson Mandela’s cabinet, and Jewish Nogal, an icon of the ANC’s liberation movement, shook the core of the Jewish establishment.
Kasrils withstood the enormity of vengeful attacks, grew in strength as his conviction to remain firmly committed to opposing Israel’s unjust apartheid rule led him to become a leading advocate for Palestinian rights.
The question is whether Beinart will withstand, survive, and lead Zionist liberals to disband their flawed support of an ideal based on settler colonialism?
Gideon Levy who is a highly respected journalist, commentator and ardent opponent of Apartheid Israel, has described Beinart’s essay as “impressive” in which he writes: “It’s time to imagine a Jewish home that is not a Jewish state.”
Fortunately, as observed by Levy, Beinart is not a lone voice in the United States. “American Jews are beginning, if belatedly, to take a clear-eyed look at Israel, its darling.”
Though the Trump administration is unashamedly in Netanyahu’s racist camp as representatives of the “elephant in the room of international relations” known as white supremacism, his flouting of global human rights conventions, makes him a foremost liability for Zionism.
The cracks created by Beinart are likely to widen beyond repair. Just as well because injustices, as illustrated by the groundswell of rage against racism and targeted discrimination embodied in “Black Lives Matter”, signifies a welcome paradigm shift.
And as Kasrils paved the way for Jewish activists in South Africa and Europe to bravely articulate Palestinian aspirations to freedom and dignity, I share Levy’s hope that Beinart’s op-ed will motivate more and more intellectuals and others to look honestly and bravely at reality, as he has done, and to say what is still considered heresy, a betrayal of Israel and not politically correct in the United States.
– Iqbal Jassat is an Executive Member of the South Africa-based Media Review Network. He contributed this article to The Palestine Chronicle. Visit: www.mediareviewnet.com
– Iqbal Jassat is an Executive Member of the South Africa-based Media Review Network. He contributed this article to The Palestine Chronicle. Visit: www.mediareviewnet.com
A few months back, a Professor of Mid-Eastern History in Italy quoted a diary entry from about 120 years back, a Jewish boy in Jerusalem was being bullied; he said it was his Muslim friends who came to his defense. They need to share the same territory as equals under the law; separate areas and separate countries will not work. Here in the U.S., a young Somali Immigrant Muslim Girl, aged 24 was elected to the City Council in a small city in Maine, getting 70% of the vote; mostly it was white non-Muslim Americans voting for her. This sort of thing needs to happen in Israel