Arab Regimes and Palestinian Statehood: A Ruthless Con

Israel continues to carry out attacks in Gaza. (Photo: social media, via QNN)

By Dr. M. Reza Behnam

Until the Arab world is liberated from kings who rule by decree and generals who rule by fear, Palestine will never have true allies.

From the opulent palaces of Persian Gulf petro-monarchs to the fortified presidential compounds of military strongmen, the political elites of the Arab world have, for nearly a century, draped themselves in the keffiyeh of Palestinian solidarity.

At every summit, in every state-controlled broadcast and on every diplomatic stage, these dictators have bellowed about al-Quds (Jerusalem) brotherhood and liberation.

It is one of the longest-running political cons in modern history.

Beneath the theatrical rhetoric lies a damning reality. Far from championing Palestinian nationalism and the realization of a sovereign Palestinian state, Arab oil and military autocrats have acted not as saviors, but as systemic jailers and cynical liquidators.

As Gaza lay in ruins and tens of thousands of Palestinians were slaughtered by relentless Israeli bombardment, Arab rulers refused to respond with economic sanctions, decisive interventions or to cut ties with the perpetrators. Instead, they met the crisis with cowardly silence, while forcefully suppressing their own outraged citizens demanding a response.

Relying on Western security guarantees and terrified of domestic unrest that might threaten their grip on power, these regimes hid behind hollow diplomatic statements and symbolic aid. By leaving Palestinians to face annihilation alone, the autocrats in Riyadh, Abu Dhabi and Cairo made it clear that regime survival and American favor carry far more weight than the blood of fellow Arabs.

That moral bankruptcy reached its most grotesque point when Qatar—a self-styled mediator and champion of the Palestinian cause—shamelessly gifted a $400 million luxury Boeing 747-8 “flying palace” to the American president. Rewarding him with an opulent jet while he finances, arms, and diplomatically shields the destruction of Gaza looks less like diplomacy and more like a celebratory tribute to Washington and its Israeli proxy for a job well done.

Rather than leverage their lucrative sovereign wealth funds to end the massacre, the petrodollar emirs, in a bid to buy influence, chose to flatter the agent of Palestinian suffering with gilded extravagance.

While external powers remain the primary architects of regional conflict and destruction, placated Arab rulers have been influential in advancing US-Israeli hegemonic ambitions. Ultimately, these self-serving, compliant oligarchs have played a major role in sabotaging Palestinian agency, motivated by the following factors:

Fear of Democratic “Contagion”

Every dictatorship dreads a functioning democracy at its threshold. This explains why Arab rulers fear a free, sovereign, democratic Palestine. The establishment of a democratic Palestinian state poses an ideological challenge to kings, emirs and generals, who justify their rule by claiming that Arabs are not ready for democratic self-governance.

Arab regimes derive their power from total control, hereditary rule or from the barrel of a gun; never from consent of the governed. For decades, the Palestinian national movement, for all its internal flaws, represented a grassroots, fiercely political mobilizing force in West Asia.

To Arab autocrats, a subordinate Palestinian proxy is a useful tool: an autonomous Palestinian state is a dangerous precedent.

From the earliest decades of the Palestinian Nakba (Catastrophe), Arab regimes have attempted to co-opt, to fracture and domesticate Palestinian leaders. When Palestinian factions acted independently, they were crushed. This occurred during Jordan’s Black September in 1970. It happened again when the Syrian military intervened against the Palestine Liberation Organization in Lebanon in 1976. And it happened again when Kuwait expelled over 300,000 Palestinian residents in the aftermath of the first Persian Gulf War in 1991.

Palestine as a Domestic Pressure Valve

For both cash-rich monarchs and bankrupt military dictators, the Palestinian cause has served as the ultimate weapon of mass distraction.

Whenever domestic economic collapse, corruption, or political repression threatens to boil over into revolution in Cairo, Riyadh, Baghdad or Amman, state media reliably turns up the volume on Palestine. By channeling their citizens’ righteous anger toward an external crisis, these regimes neutralize demands for domestic reforms, free elections and economic justice.

Across the Arab world, peaceful pro-Palestine protests are met with tear gas, mass arrests, treason charges, and prison sentences. These authoritarian regimes champion Palestine on the world stage yet criminalize solidarity at home, fearing any grassroots movement that challenges their monopoly on power.

If a sovereign Palestinian state were actually established and the conflict resolved, these dictatorships would lose their most reliable scapegoat and their primary source of manufactured moral legitimacy. They have no incentive to solve a crisis that keeps their own populations distracted and compliant.

Weaponizing Palestinian Divisions and Enforcing the Siege of Gaza

Historically, Arab regimes have fueled internal Palestinian divisions by funding rival political factions, pitting secularists against Islamists and Fatah against Hamas. They have exploited the divide, knowing that fractured leadership cannot negotiate statehood; it cannot govern a state and cannot speak with one diplomatic voice.

While voicing sympathy, the military rulers of Egypt and Jordan have enforced blockades, sealed borders, destroyed supply tunnels, and restricted both humanitarian aid and the exit of injured Palestinians from Gaza.

They have effectively acted as perimeter guards for the Gaza siege, keeping millions of Palestinian refugees in neighboring countries stateless, disenfranchised and barred from civil rights and professions under the cynical pretext of “preserving their right of return.”

The Oil-for-Impunity Bargain

The oil monarchies, sitting on trillions of dollars in sovereign wealth funds, possess immense economic and geopolitical leverage. Yet, rather than use their capital, energy dominance or diplomatic weight to compel meaningful concessions toward Palestinian statehood, they traded the Palestinian cause for regime security, Western defense guarantees and surveillance technology.

In signing the 2020 Abraham Accords, several Arab rulers formally normalized relations with Israel without securing Palestinian statehood required under the 2002 Arab Peace Initiative. In doing so, they stripped Palestinians of their last diplomatic bargaining chip, signaling that acquiring advanced weaponry and intelligence cooperation to safeguard their regimes far outweighed the survival of Palestine.

Arab oligarchs have spent decades quietly cutting deals with the Zionist regime, trading away Palestinian interests for US protection and favor. After nearly ten months of devastating war in West Asia, this shameful bargain has exposed the humiliation and profound vulnerability of these disgraced Arab regimes.

Rather than contributing positively to regional security or defending the Palestinian people, regimes that depended on American and Israeli defense guarantees have watched their curated images of power and stability crumble as drones and missiles hit their capitals, transit hubs, oil tankers, energy and military installations across Bahrain, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, Qatar, the United Arab Emirates and Jordan.

Having ceded sovereignty for foreign bases and aligned their foreign policy with US-Israeli escalation, these authoritarian rulers now find themselves the direct targets of a widening war they can neither stop nor control. They desperately scramble, pleading for de-escalation and protection, while their own populations witness the bankruptcy of autocratic dependency.

By suffocating Palestinian political independence, bankrolling internal divisions, and trading away diplomatic leverage for regime survival, Arab autocrats have cemented themselves as the enforcers of Palestinian statelessness.

Until the Arab world is liberated from kings who rule by decree and generals who rule by fear, Palestine will never have true allies—only jailers wearing the mask of brothers.

– Dr. M. Reza Behnam is a political scientist specializing in the history, politics and governments of the Middle East. He contributed this article to The Palestine Chronicle.

The views expressed in the article do not necessarily reflect the editorial position of The Palestine Chronicle.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*