SA Jewish Board of Deputies, Muslim Radio in Legal Wrangle

Dec 17 2012 / 2:51 am
radio_786_logo

By Nurah Tape – Cape Town

In what is described as a “test for South Africa’s democracy”, a community radio station in Cape Town broadcasting to a mainly Muslim audience is locked in a protracted legal battle with the South African Jewish Board of Deputies (SAJBD).

The case has been kept alive for more than a decade with both parties vying for a resolution through the courts. At one stage, it reached the highest court in the land, the Constitutional Court, resulting in key legislation being struck down.

Now, the two parties are going head on head in front of the country’s communications regulating body, the Independent Communications Authority of South Africa (ICASA), namely its Complaints and Compliance Committee (CCC).

The dispute relates to a broadcast aired on Radio 786 in 1998 wherein the topic of Zionism and the State of Israel was explored with Dr. Yaqub Zaki, a Scottish-born academic. The broadcast coincided with the 50th anniversary of Israel’s founding.

The SAJBD alleges that comments made in the broadcast amounted to hate speech.

UK Professor David Hirsch, one of its key witnesses to have taken the stand thus far, described the program as a “clear and conscious attempt to advocate for an anti-Semitic world view”.

But Radio 786’s representative for its legal team, Ali Mia Chicktay, says that in the history of the case, “no such agenda has been proven.”

“At the end of the day,” says Chicktay, “it is about criticizing Israel.”

The SAJBD, he adds, wants to dictate to the media about what they can and cannot do, what they can and cannot say.

He says the Jewish body was invited onto the station to present its views but “instead of engaging with us (Radio 786) and debating, they rejected us.”

“Because according to them, this cannot be debated. So what does this make of our democracy?”

The board’s representative, Mary Kluk, says it celebrates the fact that South Africans have a right to express themselves. “The difficulty is when that freedom crosses the line”, she says, “and amounts to hate speech.”

Kluk says people need to be sensitized as “we all know, mass atrocities, doesn’t begin with killings. It starts with words.”

According to Radio 786, the SAJBD is on record as having stated that it monitors the radio station 24 hours a day.

Chicktay questions the implications of that, saying that in 1995 with the birth of the new democracy and democratization of the airwaves, “why would an organization like the SAJBD, with their might and power, want to trip up and pounce on a small community station like 786?”

In the first three days of the hearing, the SAJBD’s witnesses who testified included the president of the SA Rabbinical Association, Rabbi Yossy Goldman. He sought to discredit the testimony to be presented by Neturei Karta Rabbis on behalf of Radio 786.

The SAJBD legal team was forced to withdraw documents it presented as evidence in the case sought to discredit the said Rabbis Aharon Cohen and Dovid Weiss.

In testimony for the SAJBD, it was suggested that even though the rabbis might have religious qualifications, they could not be regarded as such until they have a congregation. But neither their qualifications nor communal standing could be disputed by the SAJBD, as all its information was based on hearsay, said Radio 786 in a statement.

The rabbis, along with US attorney, Stanley Cohen and a Holocaust survivor, Hedy Epstein, will give testimony in Radio 786’s defense at the CCC hearing.

“In trying to discredit our witnesses, it is evident that the SAJBD is not only opposed to Radio 786 exercising its right to broadcast varied views and opinions, but that the SAJBD is also opposed to the right of these rabbis to express themselves freely on pertinent topics.”

Ultimately, what the SAJBD wants, says Kluk, is an apology from Radio 786.

This is “bully-boy tactics,” says Radio 786’s Chicktay, “these things do happen in the media.”

“We believe freedom of expression as enshrined in the Constitution guarantees that media are able to disseminate information freely such that the public is allowed to decide and freely formulate their opinions.”

The Islamic Unity Convention (IUC), which is the license holder of Radio 786, requested South Africa’s Freedom of Expression Institute (FXI) to make a submission as a friend of the court. This request was opposed by the SAJBD as it felt the FXI would side with Radio 786.

That decision by the CCC with regards to the FXI submission is still pending.

The hearing will continue in 2013.

– Nurah Tape contributed this report to PalestineChronicle.com.

image_pdfimage_print
Posted by on Dec 17 2012 . Filed under Articles, Features . You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 . You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.

Leave a Comment

Please insert the correct number.


The Free Zone | Blog

  • February 10, 2016

    Group: Israel 'Not Willing' to Solve Case of Palestinian on Hunger Strike

    The Palestinian Prisoners’ Society on Wednesday said Israel was “not showing attention or willingness” to solve the case of Palestinian journalist Muhammad al-Qiq as he entered day 77 on hunger strike. - The society reiterated that the Palestinian prisoner remained in critical condition, slamming Israel for failing to make serious steps in his case and holding Israeli authorities “completely responsible” for... More →
  • February 10, 2016

    Ex-Israeli PM to Serve 19-month Jail Term for Corruption

    Israel’s Jerusalem Magistrate on Wednesday extended a jail sentence handed down earlier against former Prime Minister Ehud Olmert after the latter was convicted on bribery charges. - Israeli daily Yedioth Ahronoth reported that Olmert, 70, would begin serving his one-year-and-seven-month sentence next Monday, becoming the first Israeli premier to serve time in jail. - He must also pay a fine of 50,000 Israeli shekels... More →
  • February 10, 2016

    Autopsy: 16-year-old Palestinian Died from Bullet to Chest

    A report from an autopsy performed on a 16-year-old Palestinian killed when clashes broke out during an Israeli military raid Tuesday revealed the teen died from a bullet to the chest. - Hebron’s District Attorney Alaa al-Tamimi told Ma'an Wednesday that Omar Yousef Madi al-Jawabreh died after being hit by a single bullet that entered his body from the right side of his chest. - Al-Tamimi said the bullet penetrated... More →
  • February 10, 2016

    Palestinians Call on Oscar Nominees to Reject Israel Propaganda Trip

    Palestinian human rights activists are calling on Oscar nominees not to accept travel vouchers supplied by the Israeli government as part of the gift bag that will be given to the nominees in the acting and directing categories. - A statement from the Israeli ministry of tourism boasted that its initiative is a chance to have “leading opinion-formers” share their visit “among millions of fans and followers”. -... More →
  • February 10, 2016

    Occupation, Colonialism and Apartheid in Israel – A Photo Essay

    By Mats Svensson - Year after year, we are still reading the same unfortunate news reports showing the evil form of Apartheid that exists in Israel today.I lived in Shuafat in East Jerusalem. I saw that evil with my own eyes. I tried to understand what was going on. - I walked along the Wall, from the south to the north. 520 km long, it snakes through Palestinian villages, destroyed olive groves and pasture lands. It... More →
Support Palestine Chronicle
Support Palestine Chronicle
"The Palestine Chronicle is a beacon. History, witness, analysis and ways forward are here, written with authority and humanity. Long may it publish." — John Pilger.
Subscribe to Newsletter
Enter your email address to subscribe to our mailing list.
Email:

Gaza As Metaphor

separator

Jerusalem Interrupted

Jerusalem Interrupted: Modernity and Colonial Transformation 1917-present

Israel And South Africa

Israel and South Africa: The Many Faces of Apartheid

Vanished

Vanished: The Mysterious Disappearance of Mustafa Ouda
Disclaimer RSS Feed Contact us Donation Popup
© Copyright 1999-2016 PalestineChronicle.com. All rights reserved
Powered By MediaSeniors